Anusol vs Preparation H: Which Is Better for Hemorrhoids? (2026)

Anusol and Preparation H are two of the most popular over-the-counter hemorrhoid treatments, but they are not the same product. Each uses different active ingredients and targets different symptoms. This guide compares them head to head so you can pick the right one, or see why neither alone may be enough.

Quick Answer

For hemorrhoids, the better choice depends on your main symptom. Preparation H uses phenylephrine to reduce swelling and comes in more forms. Anusol uses zinc oxide and pramoxine for skin protection and numbing pain relief. Choose Preparation H if swelling is your issue, and Anusol if pain or raw, irritated skin is the problem. Neither addresses the underlying cause.

HemRid MaxThe doctor-recommended hemorrhoid supplement. Clinically tested ingredients that work from the inside out.Shop Now — $33.96/mo →

See a doctor before self-treating if you have heavy rectal bleeding, severe or sudden pain, a hard painful lump, or symptoms lasting more than a week or two. Cleveland Clinic advises that over-the-counter hemorrhoid products are meant for short-term relief, and that rectal bleeding should be evaluated rather than assumed to be a hemorrhoid.

Anusol vs Preparation H: Side-by-Side Comparison

What Is Anusol?

Anusol uses zinc oxide as its primary skin protectant and pramoxine HCl as a topical anesthetic for pain. The combination shields irritated skin while numbing the area to ease discomfort.

Anusol product lineup (US):

• Anusol Ointment — zinc oxide (25%) + pramoxine HCl (1%) + mineral oil
• Anusol Suppositories — topical starch for internal soothing
• Anusol HC — hydrocortisone acetate (1%) for inflammation and itch (some formulations require a prescription)

Anusol's zinc oxide provides one of the strongest physical skin barriers of any hemorrhoid product, and the pramoxine offers genuine numbing that many users find more noticeable than Preparation H's standard ointment.

What Is Preparation H?

Preparation H is the most widely recognized hemorrhoid brand in America. Its flagship product uses phenylephrine HCl, a vasoconstrictor that narrows blood vessels to reduce swelling.

Preparation H product lineup:

• Prep H Ointment — phenylephrine HCl (0.25%) + petrolatum + mineral oil
• Prep H Rapid Relief — phenylephrine + pramoxine HCl (1%) for pain
• Prep H Anti-Itch Cream — hydrocortisone (1%)
• Prep H Suppositories — cocoa butter + phenylephrine for internal relief
• Prep H Totables Wipes — witch hazel (50%) for gentle cleansing

Preparation H's phenylephrine actively reduces swollen hemorrhoid tissue, something Anusol's standard formula does not do, and the wider product range gives more options. Learn more in our Preparation H deep dive.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Anusol if:

• Your main symptom is pain (pramoxine provides strong numbing)
• You have raw, irritated skin (zinc oxide provides an excellent barrier)
• You want a slightly cheaper option

Choose Preparation H if:

• Your main symptom is swelling (phenylephrine narrows blood vessels)
• You want more product options (wipes, sprays, multiple cream types)
• You need internal treatment (suppositories with active ingredients)

The Limitation Both Products Share

Neither Anusol nor Preparation H addresses the root cause of hemorrhoids. Both manage surface symptoms. As NIDDK explains, hemorrhoids form from pressure on the veins of the lower rectum and anus, from straining, constipation, pregnancy, prolonged sitting, and low-fiber diets. A topical cream cannot change that pressure.

That is where an inside-out option fits in. HemRid Max works from the inside with diosmin and horse chestnut, two ingredients studied for their effect on venous tone. Many people pair it with a topical during a flare. Try HemRid Max

The Best Approach: Combine Treatments

• Topical relief: use Anusol or Preparation H (or alternate) for immediate symptom management
• Inside-out support: take HemRid Max daily to support vein health from within
• Daily habits: more fiber and water, regular sitz baths, and avoiding straining and prolonged sitting

See our complete evidence-based treatment guide for more.

When to See a Doctor

If over-the-counter treatments do not help within 1 to 2 weeks, see a healthcare provider. Also see a doctor for heavy bleeding, severe pain, or a sudden hard lump that could be a thrombosed hemorrhoid. Do not assume rectal bleeding is only a hemorrhoid.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Anusol or Preparation H better for hemorrhoids?

It depends on your main symptom. Preparation H is better for swelling (phenylephrine). Anusol is better for pain and skin protection (pramoxine and zinc oxide). Both have hydrocortisone options for itching.

Can you use Anusol and Preparation H together?

You can alternate between them, but layering both at once is not recommended. Use one at a time and switch if needed.

What are the active ingredients in Anusol?

Anusol Ointment (US): zinc oxide (25%) and pramoxine HCl (1%). Anusol HC adds hydrocortisone (1%). UK formulations differ, containing bismuth and balsam peru.

Which is cheaper, Anusol or Preparation H?

Anusol tends to be slightly cheaper ($7 to $14 vs $8 to $15), but prices vary by retailer and formulation.

Do Anusol or Preparation H cure hemorrhoids?

Neither cures hemorrhoids. Both provide temporary symptom relief. For a root-cause approach, many people add an oral option with diosmin such as HemRid Max, plus more fiber and water.

References and Clinical Sources

• Hemorrhoids. Cleveland Clinic.
• Hemorrhoids: Definition and Facts. NIDDK.
• The Evaluation and Treatment of Hemorrhoids. Deutsches Ärzteblatt International, 2012.

This article is for informational purposes and does not replace professional medical advice.

Related Articles

• HemRid Max vs Preparation H: Which Is Better?
• Preparation H vs Tucks: Which Works Better?
• Preparation H vs Desitin for Hemorrhoids
• Best Hemorrhoid Treatment: Complete Evidence-Based Guide