Product Comparison

Preparation H vs Doctor Butler's (2026 Comparison)

Two popular hemorrhoid creams compared — Preparation H vs Doctor Butler's prescription-strength formula.

Preparation H

Phenylephrine vasoconstrictor

$8-15

Doctor Butler's

Lidocaine + phenylephrine + aloe

$24-30
Our Take

Doctor Butler's has stronger ingredients but costs more. Both are topical-only — consider adding HemRid Max for internal support.

Try HemRid Max →

120-day money-back guarantee · Free shipping on subscriptions

More Comparisons

HemRid Max vs Preparation H →HemRid Max vs HemRid Ultra →Preparation H vs Tucks →HemRid Lidocaine Cream vs Preparation H →